Gilded is a unique Rumpelstiltskin retelling perfect for YA fantasy fans. This complex retelling provides readers with a heroine with an interesting backstory, a villain you'll love to hate, and a story full of magic, secrets, love, and lies. (And how stunning is the cover!) **THIS REVIEW CONTAINS MAJOR SPOILERS**
My review:
Gilded was an interesting read for me. I found this book challenging, disappointing, and eventually enjoyable. I was incredibly eager to start this book, I am a huge fan of The Lunar Chronicles, but found myself disappointed by the third instalment of the Renegades trilogy, and hoped that Gilded would make up for this. As I began reading this novel I found myself falling into a reading slump but did my best to push through it. However, I did need to take a break from reading for a few weeks and only managed the first 50 pages. I was excited to return to the book as I felt there was going to be a lot to this story and I was very excited for a Rumpelstiltskin retelling. Once I picked up the novel again I found many positives and negatives to it.
Starting with the positives, I really enjoyed the world building in this novel, just as I love the world building in Meyer's previous novels. I find it easy to get sucked into the worlds that Meyer creates, and difficult to leave them. I am so excited to explore more of the world in the next book and learn more about its history.
My next positive of the book is the characters. I quickly became invested in all of the characters in Gilded, including the villain, and I am eager to learn what happens to them, and any new characters, in the sequel. Just like her previous books, I find that Meyer has created very likeable and interesting characters. I also really enjoyed the stories that were written for Serilda to tell, I found this really unique and well written, and this added a lot to the plot.
Now onto the negatives. My biggest issue with Gilded is that I found it to be far too long. The first 200 pages of the book just felt far too drawn out, and each time something interesting happened with the plot it was very short lived. I found some parts too repetitive, especially parts including the hunt, and wanted more information about the castle and the Erlking. Of course, not too much can be given away and I'm sure more will be revealed in the sequel, however, this is why I found the book to be too long. At times, it felt like there was an information overload of certain things and not enough of parts that I really wanted to explore. When looking at the size of this book I was a little unsure as to why it was so long considering Rumpelstiltskin isn't a long tale itself, and I think I would have found this to be a much more enjoyable read if it was shorter.
My second negative is something that I very much hate in YA books and I found myself very disappointed when I saw the unplanned pregnancy coming. When written in the right way this isn't something that annoys me and I do like it in adult books, but no YA books. It is a peeve of mine when the main character has sex for the first time and gets pregnant. I find it to often be pointless to the plot and very much overdone. However, the end of the novel made me a lot less annoyed with this and I can see how this is going to tie into the plot of the next book and I'm looking forward to seeing how the characters deal with this. As a reader, I just wish that we saw more of a relationship between Gild and Serilda before getting to this point.
This brings me to my next negative of the book; we didn't see all of the characters enough. I'm sure the intention is to explore Gild and the Erlking in the next book and I understand that their pasts could not have been revealed too early and there needs to be enough kept secret for the next book, but again this is why I found the book to be far too long. Also, I really wanted to see the Erlking more in this book! I felt as though the first half of the book did not include him enough considering that he is the villain.
Personally, I gave Gilded a 3.5 star rating. However, I think other readers may find this novel more enjoyable than I did and may find it to be 4 stars. I will definitely be picking up the sequel, the last 100 pages of Gilded were very enjoyable and has made me excited to read more of this story.
Tabs:
I used 59 tabs in total for this book. This was my second time using tabs whist reading. I used a lot less tabs for this read, however this book was longer than my previous read. I used my tabs as follows:
Yellow dislike/ when I was bored.
Purple quotes
Blue plot
Green surprise
Orange laugh
Red sad
Pink really liked
Unfortunately, I used more yellow tabs than I was hoping to. I used 5 yellow tabs throughout Gilded, and changed the way I had originally intended to use them. My initial intention was to use them for any parts of novel that I did not like, but I found myself using them to mark when I was getting bored of reading the book and found myself wanting to take a break. 4 out of the 5 yellow tabs were for this, with 3 of them being within the first 200 pages. After this point I found that the story really got going and was very enjoyable. The 5th yellow tab was for the unplanned pregnancy.
I used 6 purple tabs for Gilded. This is less than I thought I would use but I did find some very interesting quotes from this book;
"The wheel of fate and fortune, which, if you are wise, you know is the greatest deception of all."
"She did not remember her heart healing, and yet it seemed clear that it had."
"This was just a game to the Erlking, Predator and prey."
"Hero and villain.
The dark and the light.
There are two sides to every story."
29 blue tabs were used throughout Gilded. This was a lot more than I was expecting, but it does have a very complex and interesting plot, I just would have found it more enjoyable if it had not have been so drawn out. Following on from this, I used 7 green tabs, mostly towards the end of the book when the plot developed further.
Lastly, I used 3 red tabs, 2 orange tabs, and 2 pink tabs. There weren't many moments of this book that made me feel sad, and the ones that did were related to the difficult times Serilda had gone through. The orange and pink tabs both related to Gild. There were some moments that his sarcasm and mischief did make me laugh, and I loved his interactions with Serilda. I hope to see much more of him in the sequel, and if we do I'm sure I will use far more of these tabs then.
Who was my favourite character?
I can't say that I actually have a favourite character in Gilded. I liked Serilda, and I am looking forward to seeing her again in the sequel, but I am more looking forward to seeing Gild and the Erlking again.
How long did it take me to read?
As I found myself falling into a reading slump and finding the book very difficult to get into this one did take me a while. I began reading on November 29th, and did not complete reading it until December 16th. Once i finally got into the book, I finished the second half within two days.